Romantic Key West Restaurants


As one of the top romantic B&B’s in Key West, we see a lot of special occasions at Old Town Manor, especially anniversaries. To celebrate your many years together, you’ll probably be looking to reserve a table at one of the island’s many amazing restaurants. There is no shortage of good food or extensive wine lists in Key West. We’ve narrowed down the search for you with our favorite Key West restaurants!



Probably the most popular restaurant on the island, especially for romantic dinners, guests take a complimentary ferry from Mallory Square to Sunset Key, a private resort island. From there they will experience VIP treatment at Latitudes with one of the best wine selections in town and a phenomenal dinner menu. Don’t miss out on this exclusive Key West experience!


Italian Restaurant Key West

Photo by Lou Stejskal via Flickr



Nothing says romance like Italian food! Head over to Antonia’s for a romantic meal and some great wine. Enjoy one of their signature pasta dishes and delicious homemade focaccia. Stick around for dessert, their tiramisu is delicious!


Santiago’s Bodega

There is no better stop for a foodie couple than Santiago’s Bodega; one of Key West’s hidden gems! This place is a Spanish-style tapas restaurant where guests are invited to order several small dishes to share. Every dish is mouth-watering, we guarantee you won’t leave hungry!


Key West Restaurant - Better than Sex Dessert

Photo by Steven Miller via Flickr


Better Than Sex

Want to skip straight to dessert? Head over to one of the best Key West restaurants, Better Than Sex. With a menu entirely made of dessert, your mouth will be watering before you even take one bite. Each dish is handcrafted and unique, even the wine glasses are rimmed with chocolate and caramel!


With such a short time to spend on the island, narrowing down your dinner choices from the giant list of Key West restaurants can be hard! Each anniversary is special and we guarantee any of these places will make it feel that way. Before or after dinner, make sure to head over to Mallory Square and watch the sun set as you begin another wonderful year together!  

Eager to start planning? Check out our availability here!